Ocean view from a shaded Makena-style condominium lanai with teak lounge chairs and a glimpse of a neutral living room.

Makena Surf's 2026 Condo Sales, Floor Plan by Floor Plan

Unit E205 at Makena Surf closed for $4,200,000 in cash on February 1, 2022. It is a second-floor, two-bedroom, two-bath unit of 1,313 square feet above Poʻolenalena Beach, and it took 133 days to sell at the peak of the pandemic market. The owner then put in a new air conditioning unit, new paint, new furnishings, new lighting and new carpet in 2022. On November 4, 2025, the unit was listed again at $4,495,000. It went under contract on May 23, 2026, and closed on July 2 for $3,999,999, again in cash, after 240 days on the market.

That one unit sold twice, four years apart, and the second price came in about 5 percent under the first, with the cosmetic upgrades already paid for. This year at Makena Surf follows the same pattern. After a full year with no sales, the complex sold seven units in 2026, and the record shows the buyers came back when the prices came down.

A quiet building, then seven sales

Makena Surf is small, and its owners don't sell often. The association counts 104 units in six two- and three-story buildings, built in three stages in 1984, 1989 and 1994. Roughly 68 of those units are vacation rentals with a five-night minimum. The association's own sales page lists eight sales in 2021, five in 2022, none in 2023, three in 2024 and none in 2025. For 2026 it lists A103 and F301 in March, F207 and F108 in June, E205 in July, A101 in September and B304 in October.

The 2026 numbers are the first real read on what a Makena Surf unit is worth since the 2024 sales, and the clearest way to read them is to hold the floor plan constant.

The same 1,313-square-foot floor plan, 2021 to 2026

Makena Surf repeats a few floor plans across its buildings, so the same layout has traded over and over. All eight sales below are 1,313-square-foot, two-bedroom, two-bath units with ocean frontage, according to their MLS synopses posted by the association.

Unit Closing date Sold price Days on market
G205 March 22, 2021 $2,795,000 167
B206 May 4, 2021 $3,800,000 52
F206 July 20, 2021 $3,050,000 112
B204 August 26, 2021 $3,890,000 72
E205 February 1, 2022 $4,200,000 133
E203 June 25, 2024 $4,900,000 65
F207 June 3, 2026 $4,150,000 184
E205 July 2, 2026 $3,999,999 240

The 2024 sale of E203 sets the high-water mark, about $3,732 per square foot, and it sold in 65 days. In 2026, F207 sold for $4,150,000 and E205 for $3,999,999, about $3,161 and $3,047 per square foot. That puts them roughly 15 percent and 18 percent below E203. Both also needed about three to four times as long to sell. Position within the complex matters at Makena Surf, and the E building units carry a premium for their angle up the beach. Even so, E205 sold for less than E203, another unit in the same building, had brought two years earlier.

Other floor plans show the same reset. B304, a 1,038-square-foot beachfront unit, was listed at $3,850,000, cut to $3,495,000, and closed on October 9, 2026, for $3,250,000 after 217 days. The same layout sold for $3,800,000 as F305 in June 2022 and for $3,600,000 as G303 in May 2024. The G303 sale took 445 days, which suggests 2024's softer pricing was already showing up in the smaller units.

The 1,510-square-foot plan shows the widest gap. F108, a ground-floor unit steps from the beach, was listed at $4,695,000, reduced to $4,495,000, and sold on June 18, 2026, for $3,950,000 after 479 days on the market. In 2022 the same floor plan sold for $5,300,000 as E103 and $5,500,000 as E104. Both of those are E building units on the point. F108 also closed below the $4,000,000 that G102, another ground-floor 1,510-square-foot unit, brought in September 2021.

Why seven sales followed a year of none

Sellers lowering their asking prices accounts for most of the change. In 2026, the sale price as a share of the original asking price ran about 92 percent for F207, 90 percent for A101 and 89 percent for E205. B304 and F108 sold at about 84 percent. A101, a 1,644-square-foot ground-floor unit about 50 steps from the sand, was listed at $4,995,000 and closed on September 24 for $4,500,000 after 178 days. The largest sale of the year, A103, is a 3,415-square-foot, three-bedroom residence. It was listed at $11,995,000, reduced to $10,000,000, and closed on March 30, 2026, at $9,000,000, about 75 percent of its first asking price.

Compare the 2022 sales. E205 closed at about 97 percent of its asking price and B208 at about 99 percent. In 2024, F212 closed for $5,250,000, slightly above its $5,225,000 asking price, in 80 days. Buyers in 2026 weren't more eager than buyers in 2024. They found prices they would pay, and they took their time getting there. Every 2026 sale with recorded financing terms closed in cash.

Rental income didn't set the price

About two-thirds of the units at Makena Surf run as vacation rentals, so it would be reasonable to expect units with a booking history to hold their value better than units used only by their owners. The 2026 sales don't show that. F207 and B304 were active vacation rentals when they sold, and they took the same kind of discount as A101, which had never been rented short-term. F207 closed about 15 percent below the 2024 price for its floor plan, and B304 about 10 percent below. Buyers seem to have priced the beach, the floor plan and the position in the complex, and the rental history didn't add much.

The wider market looks the same. In the REALTORS® Association of Maui's August 2026 report, Wailea/Makena logged 55 condo sales from January through August 2026, against 56 in the same months of 2025. The median sale price fell 21.0 percent, from $2,525,000 to $1,995,000. Islandwide, the association's October 2026 report counts 688 condo closings from January through October, up from 573 a year earlier. The median was $651,250, down from $700,000, and average days on market rose to 169 from 145. Supply stood at 12.3 months in October 2026, compared with 14.6 months in October 2025. Across Maui, more condos are selling at lower prices, and Makena Surf's 2026 sales follow the same pattern.

What it costs to hold one now

Prices fell, but the monthly maintenance fee went the other way. On the 1,313-square-foot plan, the fee was $1,526.44 a month for G205, B206 and F206 in 2021. E205's fee was $1,598.48 at its 2022 sale and $1,951.56 at its 2026 sale. F207 listed $2,171.68 a month when it closed in June 2026. At those closings, ground-floor A101 listed $3,163.88 a month and the large A103 listed $6,082.95. Put the E205 figures together. A 2026 buyer paid about $200,000 less than the 2022 buyer for the same unit, and took on a monthly fee about $350 higher. These fees come from MLS records at each sale date. They are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm the current figures for any unit with the association and your own advisors.

A few questions I hear often

Is Makena Surf fee simple or leasehold? The MLS synopses for its units list fee simple ownership.

Which beach does it front? The association names Poʻolenalena, also called Paipu Beach. The complex also has two pools, tennis and pickleball courts, a fitness center and around-the-clock security.

Is anything for sale there now? In mid-November, the association's sales page showed one unit available, C106. At this building, the 2026 closing prices and days on market above give a buyer more to compare against than the asking price.

If you're weighing a unit at Makena Surf against the oceanfront buildings in Wailea, I'm happy to go through the 2026 Makena Surf closings with you, floor plan by floor plan, and compare them with what's listed now. Steve Landin is a phone call away, and a $500 donation from every transaction I close goes to a local Maui charity.

Work With Steve

Steve is here to help families buy a perfect dream home or sell a property in order to start a new life chapter. Contact him for any of your Real Estate needs!

Follow Me on Instagram